Underwater art exhibition on Porquerolles island is submerged in intrigue

On view until 17 October at Fondation Carmignac on Porquerolles, sub-aquatic group show ‘The Imaginary Sea’ (La Mer Imaginaire) frames the sea as a source of inspiration, imagination, longing and loss

Bianca Bondi, The Fall and Rise, 2021. Co-production Fondation Carmignac, Bianca Bondi and Mor Charpentier, Paris ADAGP, Paris, 2021. Photography: Marc Domage, part of the underwater art exhibition, The Imaginary Sea
Bianca Bondi, The Fall and Rise, 2021. Co-production Fondation Carmignac, Bianca Bondi and Mor Charpentier, Paris ADAGP, Paris, 2021.
(Image credit: Marc Domage)

There are many ways to view art, most of them above sea level. But this is not the case on the Mediterranean island of Porquerolles, France

At Villa Carmignac, an aptly titled new exhibition ‘The Imaginary Sea’ (La Mer Imaginaire) is being staged indoors, outdoors and underwater, transforming the foundation’s galleries into a sub-aquatic museum that plunges viewers into the bond between humans and the underwater world. From Henri Matisse, Paul Klee and Dora Maar to Lin May Saeed, Jeff Koons, Camille Henrot and Allison Katz, the participating artists are as varied as they are committed to their common subject – one of mystery, immensity and endless intrigue. 

Humanity’s relationship with the sea is complex: a source of fear, exploitation, eco-anxiety, peril and mystery. With its fusion of modern and contemporary art and site-specific installations, ‘The Imaginary Sea’ frames the marine world as a precious and evocative resource, swarming with known and unknown lives; a place of vastness, inconceivable depth, unexpected things, and also an eco-system of acute fragility. 

Micha Laury, Untitled (Les Méduses), 2006, Silicone part of an underwater art exhibition

Micha Laury, Untitled (Les Méduses), 2006, silicone. Courtesy the artist © ADAGP, Paris, 2021 – Fondation Carmignac.

(Image credit: Marc Domage)

This exhibition was the brainchild of LA-based curator Chris Sharp, co-founder of the Lulu experimental art space that is destined to become a satellite of the X Museum in Beijing. ‘The Imaginary Sea’ was inspired both by the aquarium-esque effect of the Villa Carmignac's architecture – its spaces submerged under the building’s expansive water ceiling – and by iconic works from its collection, including Bruce Nauman’s kinetic fountain with a hundred bronze fish. 

Fondation Carmignac Porquerolles opened its doors in 2018. This relatively nascent museum on a forested island in the Mediterreanian is far removed from crowds, noise and the daily grind. No more than 50 people at a time are ever permitted in the foundation's villa, sculpture park and grounds, and as coronavirus continues to grip the world, the setting provides a natural haven for those ready to dip their toes back into the waters of the art world, quite literally. 

Jeff Koons, Acrobat, 2003-2009, Fondation Carmignac Courtesy of the artist. Shimabuku, Leaves swim, 2011, Film, underwater art exhibition

Jeff Koons, Acrobat, 2003-2009, Fondation Carmignac courtesy of the artist. Shimabuku, Leaves swim, 2011, film. Courtesy of the artist and Air de Paris. 

(Image credit: Marc Domage)

Elsewhere, Miquel Barceló has transformed the vaulted gallery into an organic underwater grotto, and Jeff Koons’ inflatable lobster sculpture engages in some chair-to-chair gymnastics. In another episode of sea life-meets-furniture, Cosima Von Bonin’s fabric Killer Whale sits eagerly at a school desk. In another striking intervention, Bianca Bondi presents her new The Fall and Rise, 2021, a life-size whale skeleton created in resin and salt. Beyond the foundation walls, in a 15th-century fort, photographer Nicholas Floc’h’s exhibition entitled ‘Invisible/Parallel’ is a literal take on submersion. In partnership with the Port-Cros National Park and the Villa Noailles, the photographer has transformed the seabed into a landscape, documenting the more concerning aspects of oceanic change.

‘The Imaginary Sea’ is also a potent reminder that our undersea world, 95 per cent of which is still uncharted, is now endangered. Without action, we are facing a world where many marine creatures and organisms may exist only in our imaginations, or that of artists.

Melik Ohanian, Shell, 2014, courtesy of the artist and Galerie Chantal Crousel, Paris ADAGP, Paris, 2021; Bruce Nauman, Fondation Carmignac.

Melik Ohanian, Shell, 2014, courtesy of the artist and Galerie Chantal Crousel, Paris ADAGP, Paris, 2021; Bruce Nauman, Fondation Carmignac. Courtesy of the artist. ADAGP, Paris, 2021. 

(Image credit: Marc Domage)

Part of the underwater art exhibition the Imaginary sea Gabriel Orozco, Spume 5, 6, Splash, 2003. Courtesy of the artist and Marian Goodman Gallery New York/London/Paris; Henri Matisse, 1964, Tapisserie Ville de Beauvais © Succession H. Matisse.

Gabriel Orozco, Spume 5, 6, Splash, 2003. Courtesy of the artist and Marian Goodman Gallery New York/London/Paris; Henri Matisse, 1964, Tapisserie Ville de Beauvais © Succession H. Matisse

(Image credit: Marc Domage)

INFORMATION

’The Imaginary Sea’, until 17 October 2021, Villa Carmignac, Porquerolles island, fondationcarmignac.com

Harriet Lloyd-Smith was the Arts Editor of Wallpaper*, responsible for the art pages across digital and print, including profiles, exhibition reviews, and contemporary art collaborations. She started at Wallpaper* in 2017 and has written for leading contemporary art publications, auction houses and arts charities, and lectured on review writing and art journalism. When she’s not writing about art, she’s making her own.

Read more
dark oil paintings
‘You have to face death to feel alive’: Dark fairytales come to life in London exhibition
art
‘Artists are being asked to be vulnerable’: inside the Sharjah Biennial 2025
stills of people in a film
'I don’t want to see culture always falling for formulas': inside Doug Aitken's ambitious cinematic installation in LA
desert
Desert X 2025 review: a new American dream grows in the Coachella Valley
art works
Don't miss these five artists at Art Basel Hong Kong
Colourful ceramic vessels on plinths, and artworks on walls, in Mutina ceramics exhibition
Ceramics brand Mutina stages a poetic tribute to everyday objects
Latest in Exhibitions & Shows
frida kahlo
A major Frida Kahlo exhibition is coming to the Tate Modern next year
art works
Don’t miss these five artists at Art Basel Hong Kong
ai weiwei
Ai Weiwei's major retrospective in Seattle is a timely and provocative exploration of human rights
grayson perry
A portrait of the artist: Sotheby’s puts Grayson Perry in the spotlight
desert
Desert X 2025 review: a new American dream grows in the Coachella Valley
cowboy
Cowboys and Queens: Jane Hilton's celebration of culture on the fringes
Latest in Feature
lean lui guide to hong kong
A local’s guide to Hong Kong, by photographer Lean Lui
Perfume Genius Glory album artwork
Inside the visual universe of Perfume Genius
art works
Don’t miss these five artists at Art Basel Hong Kong
best hotels hong kong
Where to stay in Hong Kong
jewellery
Bold colours and tactile textures: inside Bottega Veneta's second fine jewellery drop
waiheke island new zealand guide
Waiheke Island is a must-visit for oenophiles and aesthetes alike